TurboTax vs TaxSlayer: Low Cost Meets Premium Polish
Heads up: InstallTurboTax.us is an independent, taxpayer-friendly help site. We are not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Intuit Inc. or TurboTax®, and we are here only to make your tax software easier to use. Always verify pricing and features on the official TurboTax site. Full disclaimer.
TaxSlayer is a long-running budget tax program known for its low-cost tiers and a self-employed plan that's a favorite with freelancers and gig workers. It covers the forms most of us need and prices well below TurboTax, especially for self-employment income, which tends to be the expensive area in other software.
As with most value options, the trade-off is lighter guidance and a less polished interface. TurboTax invests heavily in walking you through your return and importing your data automatically. If you don't need that level of support, TaxSlayer can file the same return for less. Here's the breakdown.
TurboTax vs TaxSlayer: at a glance
| Feature | TurboTax | TaxSlayer |
|---|---|---|
| Starting price (paid federal) | ~$69 (Deluxe) | ~$25–40 (mid tier) |
| Self-employed tier price | ~$129 (online) | Often well below TurboTax |
| Free edition for simple returns | Yes (qualifying 1040s) | Yes (simple situations) |
| Ease of use / guidance | Very polished | Functional, lighter touch |
| Data import (W-2/1099) | Broad partner network | More limited |
| Expert help available | Yes (Live, extra cost) | Yes (Ask a Tax Pro, by tier) |
| Accuracy / refund guarantee | Yes | Yes |
| State return | Extra fee | Extra fee (often lower) |
| Best for | Guided, polished filing | Budget filers, freelancers |
Pricing notes
TaxSlayer's pricing is one of its biggest draws, and the gap is especially noticeable on self-employment returns, where TurboTax tends to get expensive. You trade some guidance and import convenience for those savings. Both providers run seasonal promotions and charge separately for state returns, so the approximate figures above will move around. Confirm the current numbers on each official site before you file.
TurboTax
- ✓A polished, thorough interview that explains tax concepts as you go
- ✓A broad import network that keeps manual data entry to a minimum
- ✓Strong, reassuring guidance for investments and self-employment
- ✓A mature online and mobile experience
- ✕It's more expensive than TaxSlayer at comparable tiers
- ✕The self-employed online tier in particular costs significantly more
- ✕Upgrade prompts can nudge you toward a pricier edition
TaxSlayer
- ✓Low-cost tiers that undercut TurboTax across the board
- ✓A self-employed plan that freelancers love for its value
- ✓Covers the core forms most of us need
- ✓Backed by accuracy and maximum-refund guarantees
- ✕Lighter guidance and a plainer interface than TurboTax
- ✕Fewer automatic import options, so more manual entry for you
- ✕Whether you get expert help depends on which tier you buy
Bottom line
TurboTax is the better choice if you want a guided, polished experience with strong imports and detailed help, particularly for complicated returns. TaxSlayer is the smarter pick if you're watching your budget, and it's especially appealing for freelancers thanks to its low-priced self-employed tier. If you're confident handling your own numbers, TaxSlayer delivers strong value; if you'd rather the software do more of the thinking and importing for you, TurboTax justifies its higher price.
Frequently asked questions
Is TaxSlayer good for self-employed filers?＋
Yes, it is. TaxSlayer's self-employed tier is a popular, value-focused option for freelancers and gig workers with 1099 income and business expenses. It typically costs less than TurboTax's equivalent, with somewhat lighter guidance.
Does TaxSlayer offer expert help like TurboTax?＋
TaxSlayer gives you access to tax professionals on certain tiers, similar in spirit to TurboTax Live but generally more limited. TurboTax's live expert options are more extensive, though they cost more.
Is TaxSlayer accurate compared with TurboTax?＋
Both apply the same tax rules and back their calculations with accuracy guarantees. Accuracy really comes down to entering your data correctly; TurboTax simply offers more guidance to help you do that.
Was this page helpful?
Comments
Loading comments…
Join the discussion
Sign in with your email to leave a comment. Comments appear after approval.